When teams talk about code quality, bugs, and technical debt, one name comes up again and again:
Sonar
But very often, developers ask:
- Should I use SonarQube?
- Or SonarCloud?
- Aren’t they the same?
They solve the same problem, but in very different ways.
Let’s break it down clearly.
What Problem Do They Solve?
Both SonarQube and SonarCloud help you:
- Detect bugs
- Identify code smells
- Find security vulnerabilities
- Measure code coverage
- Enforce quality gates
In short:
They stop bad code from reaching production.
What Is SonarQube?
SonarQube is a self-hosted code quality platform.
You install and manage it yourself:
- On your own server
- On a VM
- On Docker
- Inside your company network
Key Characteristics
- Full control over setup
- Requires maintenance
- Works even without internet (internal repos)
Typical Users
- Enterprises
- Banks
- Companies with strict security policies
What Is SonarCloud?
SonarCloud is a cloud-hosted version of Sonar, fully managed by SonarSource.
You:
- Don’t install anything
- Don’t manage servers
- Just connect your repository
Key Characteristics
- Zero maintenance
- SaaS-based
- Tight CI/CD integration
Typical Users
- Startups
- Open-source projects
- Small to mid-sized teams
Real-World Analogy
SonarQube
🏠 Owning a house
- You choose everything
- You maintain everything
- More responsibility, more control
SonarCloud
🏨 Living in a hotel
- No maintenance
- Pay and use
- Less control, more convenience
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | SonarQube | SonarCloud |
|---|---|---|
| Hosting | Self-hosted | Cloud-hosted |
| Setup | Manual | Instant |
| Maintenance | Required | None |
| Scalability | Your responsibility | Automatic |
| Cost | Free + Paid editions | Subscription |
| CI/CD Integration | Manual | Built-in |
| Security Control | Full | Limited |
| Internet Required | No | Yes |
| Best For | Enterprises | Startups & OSS |
Installation vs Configuration
SonarQube
Steps include:
- Installing Java
- Setting up a database
- Managing upgrades
- Configuring backups
SonarCloud
Steps include:
- Sign in
- Connect GitHub/GitLab/Bitbucket
- Run CI pipeline
✔ Done.
CI/CD Integration
SonarQube
- Requires manual pipeline configuration
- Needs scanner setup
SonarCloud
- Native integration
- Auto PR decoration
- Quality gate feedback directly on PRs
Security & Compliance
SonarQube
✔ Works inside private networks
✔ Suitable for sensitive codebases
SonarCloud
❌ Source code leaves your network
✔ Still secure, but cloud-based
Supported Languages
Both support:
- Java
- JavaScript
- TypeScript
- Python
- C#
- Go
- And many more
➡ Language support is almost identical
Pricing Model
SonarQube
- Community edition (Free)
- Developer, Enterprise editions (Paid)
- Cost depends on lines of code
SonarCloud
- Free for public repos
- Paid for private repos
- Subscription-based
When Should You Use What?
Choose SonarQube if:
- You need full control
- You work in a restricted network
- Compliance is critical
- You have DevOps resources
Choose SonarCloud if:
- You want zero maintenance
- You are a small or fast-moving team
- You use GitHub/GitLab CI
- You prefer SaaS tools
Common Misunderstanding
❌ “SonarCloud is just SonarQube online”
✔ Reality:
Same engine, different operating model.
Final Thoughts
Both tools are excellent.
The real question is not:
“Which one is better?”
But:
“Which one fits my team and workflow?”
Good code quality is not optional —
how you enforce it is a choice.
Discover more from Learners Store
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
